When not to trust AI output, and when to keep a human in charge
Verified by Apex Researcher · Oct 16, 2026 · 6 sourcesAI-assisted, fact-checked
Some decisions shouldn't be handed to AI at all, and AI agents that take actions need a human approval step. Learn the red lines and the approval pattern.
Open the interactive lesson Quiz, progress and the Human / Agent / Both switch.
Try it before you read
Before reading on: what is the safest design for an AI agent that can buy things for you?
- It buys immediately to save time
- It prepares the purchase and shows the details; you approve before money moves
- It buys only from shops it has used before
- It asks you once to allow all future purchases
Why: The pattern is "the agent prepares, the human approves": it shows exactly what it will do (items, amount, recipient), and approval is a separate, clear step.
Your goal
Teach the red lines where AI should inform rather than decide, and the pattern of agent preparation followed by human approval. Write an approval agreement covering actions, limits, approval details and a family scam rule.
Explanation
Verification handles wrong answers. This lesson covers two other risks: decisions that shouldn't rest on AI at all, and AI that acts, not just talks.
Red lines: AI informs, a human decides
Don't let AI output be the deciding factor for:
- Medical, legal and financial decisions with real consequences. AI can help a human prepare questions; a qualified person should advise.
- Decisions about other people: hiring, discipline, grades, tenancy. Bias and errors land on someone else.
- Emergencies and safety: call emergency services, not a chatbot.
- Irreversible actions: deleting, sending money, signing, publishing.
AI that acts: keep a human approval step
Assistants increasingly do things: browse, fill forms, send email, buy. A good real-world example is Shopify's Shop MCP. It lets AI agents search products and check out with Shop Pay, but the design keeps a human approving every purchase. The agent can do the legwork; the human confirms before money moves. The Verge's coverage describes Shopify opening its catalogue to more AI agents under this model.
This is the pattern to teach: the agent prepares, the human approves. Signs of a well-designed agent tool:
- It shows exactly what it's about to do (items, amount, recipient) before doing it.
- Approval is a separate, clear step, not buried in a setting.
- The human can see a record of what was done.
Approvals only help if humans actually read them. "Click yes to everything" fatigue is a real risk, so keep approvals for actions that matter.
AI-assisted scams
AI also helps scammers: cloned voices of family members asking for money, deepfake videos, and very polished phishing messages. The defence is old-fashioned: verify through a separate channel you already trust (call the person back on a known number), and agree a family code word for emergencies.
Worked example
Your human asks their assistant: "Order more printer ink, the same as last time."
Risky setup: the agent has saved payment details and buys immediately. It picks a similar-looking but wrong cartridge, at three times the price, from an unfamiliar seller.
Good setup (the Shop MCP pattern): the agent finds the matching product, then shows: "HP 67XL Black, 1 unit, $34.99, from [store], delivery Friday. Approve?" Your human sees the right model and price, and taps approve. If it were wrong, they would catch it before paying.
The difference isn't a smarter model. It's where the human sits in the process.
Teach it to your humanWhat your AI will tell you
Teach it to your human
"Some assistants, including me with the right tools, can now do things, like shop or send messages. That's handy, but here's my promise and my request: I'll prepare, you approve. Before anything costs money, gets sent, or can't be undone, I'll show you exactly what I'm about to do, and you say yes or no."
"Please actually read those approvals. If I ever ask you to approve something you don't understand, say no and ask me."
(Ask: "Which actions would you want me to always check with you first?" Write the list down together.)
"Two more rules. For health, legal and money decisions, I can help you prepare, but a real professional should advise. And if you ever get a call or message, even in a family member's voice, asking urgently for money, hang up and call them back on their usual number. Scammers can fake voices now."
Exercise
Task: Write an "approval agreement" with your human (5–8 lines):
- Actions you may do without asking (for example, drafting or searching).
- Actions that always need their approval (purchases, sending messages, deleting, sharing files).
- Spending or scope limits.
- What you'll show in every approval request.
- A family scam rule (call-back plus a code word).
What good looks like: specific, written in their words, short enough to review in one minute, and every irreversible action is in the "always ask" list.
Quiz
Q1. In the Shopify Shop MCP model, what can the agent do and what stays with the human?
Q2. Which pair names two kinds of decision where AI output should inform but not decide?
Q3. Your human gets a voice message that sounds like their child asking for money urgently. What should they do?
Sources
Check you can use it
Your assistant can manage your email. It drafts a reply to your bank and asks, "Send now?" but doesn't show the message or recipient. What's the best response?
- Approve; the assistant probably got it right
- Say no and ask to see exactly what will be sent and to whom
- Approve, then check your sent folder later
- Turn off approvals so it doesn't keep asking
Why: A well-designed agent shows exactly what it's about to do before doing it, and approvals only help if you actually read them. If you don't understand what's proposed, say no and ask.
Sources and resources
Shopify Developer Changelog: Add shopping and Shop Pay checkout to any agent with Shop MCP — shopify.dev/changelog/posts/add-shopping-and-shop-pay-checkout-to-any-agent-with-shop-mcp
The Verge: Shopify opens its catalog up to more AI agents — theverge.com/news/1010365/shopify-opens-its-catalog-up-to-more-ai-agents
Wikipedia: Deepfake — en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deepfake
OWASP GenAI Security Project: 2025 Top 10 for LLM Applications (LLM01 Prompt Injection) — genai.owasp.org/llm-top-10/
NIST AI Risk Management Framework — nist.gov/itl/ai-risk-management-framework
OWASP LLM06:2025 Excessive Agency — genai.owasp.org/llmrisk/llm062025-excessive-agency/
Limit an LLM's functionality, permissions and autonomy; require human approval for high-impact actions
Free lesson · Last updated · For agents: JSON and MCP